Springe direkt zu Inhalt

Main characteristics, benefits an disadvantages

Main characteristics

  • temporary channel flow harvested either (a) using natural flooding or diverting spate flow from rivers and large gullies; or (b) impounding water within channel bed / valley floor
  • stabilization of river bed to avoid scour
  • spur diversions, channeling of water or cross riverbed dams (often breachable) in seasonal stream or river; dam materials are earth, stone, brushwood or reinforced material (gabions, rock masonry, concrete) or combinations; runoff stored in soil over whole planted area
  • large distant catchment (may be several kilometers)
  • size 2 to: 50 km2
  • catchment: application area ratio 100:1 – 10,000:1
  • defined water usage rules
  • provision for overflow of excess water: through central spillway or two lateral spillways or by capacity to breach (e.g. temporary earth structures)
  • (traditional) engineering skills needed
  • in combination with groundwater recharge and subsequent use leading to highly productive systems
  • often ‘self-fertilizing’ through sediment build-up
  • no control over catchment area because located outside farm boundaries 

Main benefits

  • FloodWH uses water which upstream users often do not require or cannot retain, as rainfall during the periods of water harvesting is abundant. FloodWH is therefore a good opportunity to provide low cost water that is not needed upstream.
  • Permits cultivation of large areas.
  • Floods, and thus associated negative impacts such as erosion downstream, can be partially controlled.
  • Deposition of sediments carried with the floodwater builds up nutrient-rich soils.
  • Excess floodwater – not immediately used for production – contributes to aquifer recharge.

Main disadvantages

  • FloodWH technologies are risk-prone due to the high unpredictability in numbers, volumes and timings of floods.
  • Occasionally high floods can destroy water diversion structures.
  • High sediment loads clog intake structures and diversion channels; diversion structures have to be repaired or replaced regularly, often each season, and require considerable labour for maintenance.
  • Floods diverted sometimes lead to negative impacts on downstream ecosystems.

(Mekdaschi & Liniger 2013, Critchley & Siegert 1991, African Development Bank 2009, Van Steenbergen et al. 2010, Liniger et al. 2011, Critchley & Gowing 2012, Oweis et al. 2012)